All Comments


Comment on piece: Dick Cheney, Conservative Shock Jock

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Dick Cheney, Conservative Shock Jock

I like Kessler’s politics and he makes a fine point. He’s a good political satirist, in the old school sense. I like his fast-talking, too-- it’s just that sometimes he’s just too fast to properly enjoy the full breadth of his thoughts. As always, these super short essays would make a nice drop in to a morning show. His speed would make such an interesting contrast to a lot of slower deadpan readers on the air.

Comment on piece: Avital Under Fire

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Avital Under Fire

The carpe diem aspect of Avital’s story is moving. A bit more could have been drawn out to connect the suicide bombing and the venture to NYC to become a singer. As it stands, we are merely presented with the suggestive proximity of the two events. Avital’s a nice subject, I just feel like the story might have been richer if we were given more anecdotes and more scenes to get more of a sense of who she is.

Comment on piece: El Padre y Los Homies

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of El Padre y Los Homies

Homeboy industries employs ex-gang members. It sounds like a very worthwhile project, and the virtues of the program are extolled, but It would have been great to hear some actual stories about what lead certain kids into the gangs in the first place. We know the gangs must hold some allure, even if it’s one born of self-destructiveness. There’s hardly any of that, in concrete terms, so things tend towards being a bit public servicy. The announcer sounds a lot like one of the reporters from The Daily Show—which made me think, why can’t a piece like this have an element of humor to it, too? “As one life tragically ends, another starts,” says the announcer, and it just sounds a little pat. Too much Easter Sunday, and not enough good Friday. Still, the message is a positive one, and the original score is lovely.

Comment on piece: My Future Self, Age 30

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of My Future Self, Age 30

Very elusive. I think it’s about18 year olds pretending to be 30, but I’m not sure that it is. To leap ahead 12 years, rather casually, and then have nothing really is a potentially interesting idea. It’s like a real-life Twilight Zone. It reminds me of the film Stargate, where scientists pass through a nexus into another dimension and they just sort of walk around with nothing to do. I’m not sure on what level we are to experience the actual leap ahead in time, but the dialogue that takes place is quite charming.

Comment on piece: The Olfactograph

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of The Olfactograph

Jamie O’Shea’s Olfactograph turns objects into smells. The sense of smell is so intimately connected to memory, that it’s like he is creating a potion that acts as a nexus to the past. He has even distilled the scent of a bath toy down to a liquid. For the most part, the sound in the piece interacts nicely with O’Shea’s voice, creating a rather impressionistic, cinematic effect. What I would have enjoyed is more about how he became so obsessed with smell that he decided to create such an oddity. It would have given the whole thing a more personal dimension. Still, an audio piece about smell does show moxy. This could fit nicely in to a magazine show.

Comment on piece: The Organ Builder

User image

Review of The Organ Builder

Good character, good ambience. The story is okay as it stands, but while I appreciate all the different things that seem to deserve explanation in the world of the pipe organ, the piece could be trimmed down to 5 mins or less without much damage.

Comment on piece: Stencil Pirates

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Stencil Pirates

An interesting interview, and one with a message; it's not earth-shatteringly profound, but it's clever. It would suit a drive-home show.

Comment on piece: Hell's Bells

User image

Review of Hell's Bells

A wonderful way to start a serious and intelligent discussion of faith -- not a set-up for an argument or a "debate," but the start of a discussion that really hasn't been aired (at least within my hearing) on public radio.

Thoughtfulness is a hallmark of Anderson's work, but this will come as a surprise to those acquainted with his other pieces. Nice drop in for the likes of WESUN.

Comment on piece: Hell's Bells

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Hell's Bells

Hans Anderson is a great candidate because he doesn't shy away from the issues! But he manages to do it with a light touch. He uses the story of a dream as tool to examine an old, central question. And the piece gave me a new appreciation for music I hadn't liked before.

Comment on piece: Stencil Pirates

User image

Review of Stencil Pirates

Some might find stencil art offensive, but in this well-recorded interview, an articulate artist explains the process involved in creating what he calls “art messages,” and his philosophy of offering an unexpected art experience to people who don’t necessarily visit galleries or museums. There’s risk involved in this less-than-legal endeavor, but as he points out, these days, many forms of public expression are risky. Interesting profile, and the sound of the spray can is so sharp you can practically smell the toxins. Good “fill” length.

Comment on piece: Norman Mailer Interview

User image

Review of Norman Mailer Interview

At first I thought that perhaps the interviewer was directing Mailer too much, particularly with his first question, but it turns out that it was a really astute move in that Mailer took that question/observation and ran with it, as he did with all the questions. Setting him up with observations about his past work and tying it to the present is a great skill. I think I enjoyed the questions about as much as Mailer's answers. Mailer loves to talk and has never been shy about sharing his views. He's certainly true to form here. Excellent work. I'm sure this interview will be heard in a number of markets.

Comment on piece: Turnstyles 004 Hour 1: Gaby Kerpel

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Turnstyles 004 Hour 1: Gaby Kerpel

I really like the quality of Turnstyles interviews, this now being the 3rd show in the series that I've aired. The questions are pertinent and just leading and thoughtful enough, and the interviews never seem to drag due to nice usage of the artist's music interspersed during the Q+A. The rest of the show is progressive, and I like most of the music. I think Sam could loosen up a bit during the breaks and let it go a bit -- it's fun, relaxing music and the host should reflect! But he does a nice job. This is a great series for the weekend.

Comment on piece: Musical Injuries

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Musical Injuries

Great interviews! This could have been a dry subject if the human element in this wasn't played up so well. Nice editing job. I think the nat.sound related to the music could have been placed a little bit better throughout the piece, esp. during the interviews, rather than just dropped in the beginning and at the end. But I'm still liking this a bunch.

Comment on piece: Hungry March Band

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Hungry March Band

Rock and roll! Come play on my street! These folks are wacky and fun and I like it. This is one of those works where the production could be awful and the piece would still fly because the suject is compelling and sound-rich. But the production IS good, so there's the icing. It's hard to go wrong with the carnivalesque. Everyone should air this or at least give it a listen.

Comment on piece: Plus One

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Plus One

Smooth and entertaining, maybe rambling a bit too much, but it makes sense considering the subject and the perspective, these girls who try to fight themselves from becoming too enamored with the rock and roll lifestyle they aren't interested in living but somehow can't stop being hooked on. The funny thing is that these "rock" bands, as noted in the piece, are not bands that are going to hit it big, leaving their significant others wondering where the excitement in their relationship is coming from -- probably not from watching their boyfriends chug beer in the parking lot. This feels like a rainy day magazine-style piece.

Comment on piece: Norman Mailer Interview

User image

Review of Norman Mailer Interview

Lydon and Mailer, what a fabulous pairing. A shared love of language, and interest in cultural investigation make for a fast-paced, intelligent and fascinating twenty minutes. The conversation is filled with pithy insights into the essential makeup of the presidential candidates, the country, and the perishable nature of democracy, among other matters. Snappy quotes abound. Production notes offer a few of the many highlights. The length is long for morning or afternoon NPR, but it’s so worth airing, in two parts if need be. Lydon ends by saying it’s been “a pleasure and a privilege to talk…” as it is to listen. This is a must air.

Comment on piece: The Parents of PFC Nick Spry

User image

Review of The Parents of PFC Nick Spry

This is a very sad acapella duet (though you can practically hear cello accompaniment) in memory of #538 on the list of American hearts stilled in our so-called preemptive war against Iraq. Nick was just eight months out of high school when he left these shores. The tears in his mother’s voice, the wrung-out calm in his father’s are powerful reminders of the torture so many family members undergo while waiting for their soldiers to come home. It is all the sadder to hear that both parents felt in their heart of hearts that Nick would not return. A fitting ME or ATC drop-in length.

Comment on piece: Olympic Puppeter

User image

Review of Olympic Puppeter

Having missed the opening ceremonies, I can’t testify as to whether the profiled puppeteer’s touch was apparent. This straightforward conversation/report focuses on the puppeteer’s background and approach to pageantry production. It’s timely if aired right quick, of local interest to Philadelphians, and includes an insightful comment on how ill-thought-out pageants can go awry.

Comment on piece: Tippecanoe and Tyler Too!

User image

Review of Tippecanoe and Tyler Too!

Nicely produced piece on convention history that includes a sentence about looking through the rear end of a pig, (not literally, of course). This brings to mind many wry comments about conventions upcoming and past, all of which I will spare you. More to the point, this foray backwards is a pleasant balance for coverage on present day conventions, so expensively packaged for both viewer and attendee.

Comment on piece: Giving Radio

User image

Review of Giving Radio

I love this piece. It takes the listener through Joshua's family and into our own world of life-long relationships. I can, however, see that it would be embarrassing for all to sit in a circle at her birthday party to listen. So it is a difficult birthday gift. It is meant for the solitary experience of radio. Seems to me that this would be a good piece for This American Life.