Comments by Helen Woodward

Comment for "Orphan Opossums"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Orphan Opossums

Part confessional, part first person essay, about a families brush with local wildlife. A tad gory for the sensitive possum lovers amongst us, but a story with heart nonetheless . Might be easier to air (during ATC or ME as a welcome break from hard news), time wise if it was a tad shorter; an engaging voice, telling a tale that some of us, as human's increasingly encroaching on the natural environment have already experienced, or will do in the future.

Comment for "W.T.O. Protesters Reflect on Cancun"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of W.T.O. Protesters Reflect on Cancun

This piece provides a behind the scenes look at the WTO protests in Mexico in September 2003, from the perspective of several US protesters; it uses the benefit of hindsight to reflect on the problems and successes associated with the protests and touches on the links made between the disparate groups endure.

This piece could provide some context for the upcoming G8 meeting in Georgia in early June, which is expected to be heavily protested by many anti-global trade groups, and puts a human face, or at least a human voice on the motivations of the protest movement.

Comment for "Torturing Terrorists (es#57)" (deleted)

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Torturing Terrorists (es#57) (deleted)

A plain-speaking and brief discussion of an ethical dilemma, in this case, the torturing of captured "terrorists". This piece might over-simplify things (if all ethical problems could be solved in 2 minutes the world would surely be a better place) but it does address important issues in a simple and easily understood fashion, and allows feedback through a website, and as such encourages a dialogue, a laudable and essential ingredient in developing an ethical life. If this is part of a series, which I believe it is, it could be aired as a regular spot during ME or ATC and make a good addition to those shows.

Comment for "Fulton Fish Market"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Fulton Fish Market

This piece provides a thorough overview of the existing market, the sounds and the characters, and touches on the potential problems associated with the pending move to the Bronx. Packed with facts and figures, and sad reflections on the state of the fishing economy (eg. hardly any fish arrive by boat anymore, the tractor trailer is the name of the game these days), this piece paints a complex picture of the issues surrounding the move and as such would be a welcome addition to any show on the fishing or food industry.

Comment for "Profile of a (Reality) Composer"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Profile of a (Reality) Composer

This piece focuses on the only aspect of reality TV that is in anyway real, and as such it provides an interesting (if brief) insight into the life of a modern-day musician with all the hightech gizmos he relies on. It provides historical perspective against a backdrop of familiar TV theme tunes and throws in a few surprising details like the fact that the Simpsons is one of only a few TV shows that uses a full orchestra for it's soundtrack. It is engaging and moves along nicely though it ends rather abruptly.

Comment for "Viagra: Medical and social effects of Viagra."

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Viagra:

Viagra and other medications that address erectile disfunction are so omnipresent on TV and the internet, and absent on public radio as far as I am aware, that this piece's time may have come. According to the subject of this interview, erectile dysfuction affects 52% of men over 40 to some extent. This suprising statistic makes the barrage of advertisments and emails that we are exposed to daily a little easier to accept. The piece comprises a very indepth interview that covers all apsects of the viagra phenomenom, from diagnosis and prescription, to overuse and abuse, and puts it in the context of heterosexual relations. It clearly deals with the subject matter from a male perspective and oversimplifies the female side of things a little, but nevertheless it is an important issue and this is an informative interview. As for airing, the subject matter is inevitably going to raise a few eyebrows, but it is dealt with in a mature fashion and is not overly graphic, so I wouldn't have any qualms about airing it at any time. I appreciated that the interviewee did not continually plug his book; I find it grating when every answer to a question is prefaced with "well in my book you will find....."!

Comment for "Turtles"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Turtles

I liked this piece a lot. It is visual and honest without being mean-spirited. The speaker is an engaging story teller, and a keen observer of the human condition; the work is well-scored to quirky music that pulls the listener along, it is present but not in your face.

I cant quite identify when this could be aired, but it should be.

Comment for "Outsource This!"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Outsource This!

I found the speaker soooooo incredibly fast that I had to listen 3 times to grasp what was being said, and I felt all breathless and anxious at the end of it. That being said once I did understand what was going on valid points were made, often humorously, and as outsourcing is the word of the day these days this commentary could be aired during ME or ATC.

Comment for "The Allure of Karaoke Singing"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of The Allure of Karaoke Singing

Karaoke - the great equalizer. As someone in this piece says, everyone likes to sing in the car, and karaoke takes that desire to the next level. This piece has the right balance of self-deprecation and amateur performances, it is entertaining and fun and it is over just as you begin wondering where karaoke afficionados hang out in your town. Who doesn't have a secret desire to sing neil diamond songs with abandon?

Comment for "The Tongass National Forest Part Two"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of The Tongass National Forest Part Two

An engaging (and unfortunately less uplifting) follow up to part 1. The complex interactions between all the elemnts of the Tongass habitat are explained in a clear and comprehensible fashion, and both sides of the logging picture are presented here in an even-handed way. The piece clearly demonstrates the dilemma faced by locals who rely on the forests for their livelihood, and yet recognize the need to protect the dwindling resource. It is somewhat disconceting to hear that cutting down trees is "more fun than kissing pretty girls", but maybe this off-the-cuff statement demonstrates just how wide the cultural divide is between loggers and those wishing to protect the trees.

Comment for "The Tongass National Forest Part One"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of The Tongass National Forest Part One

Information-packed, engaging piece that makes you want to head straight for the Alaskan wilds. Alongside our host we visit fishing grounds, old-growth forests and caves and meet a variety of naturalists full of unbridled enthusiasm for the natural world. An excellent addition to any show focusing on environmental issues, it is like taking a mini aural field trip from the comfort of your own home.

Comment for "Disturbing The Queen Worm. . . Offramp"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Disturbing The Queen Worm

This didn't quite work for me, but perhaps I couldn't suspend the scientist/realist in me sufficiently to go with the flow; the improvised nature of this work is interesting, I liked the characters: 3 old geezers indulging in idle banter, but I felt the piece could have been more satisfying if it had been shorter.

Comment for "Doing Time: John's Diary"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Doing Time: John's Diary

This is a revealing and challenging first-person piece, an excellent and affecting example of its genre. The overall impression is of an environment that is loud, jarringly loud; replete with inmates (if this diarist is representative) whose potential to change/make amends is being squandered by the prison system. The piece is filled the mundane details of daily life behind bars: smoke breaks, watching ricki lake, endless hours in the cell. The diarist is honest and intimate, and the piece is seamlessly constructed.

Comment for "Thirty" (deleted)

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Thirty (deleted)

This heartfelt piece is a free-flowing journey through many people's memories of the lives and deaths of 2 friends. Beyond the memorialising it has a broader appeal, touching on what we leave behind, and the long term impact we all have on those around us.

Could provide fodder for discussion on shows about legacy, death, loss and grieving.

One technical note: there is a recurring clicking sound, most prevalent in first 30 seconds or so; pretty sure this isn't meant to be there, could be an uploading issue or something!?
HW

Comment for "Democracy, American-Style: "Wanted: Smarter Citizens""

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Democracy, American-Style: "Wanted: Smarter Citizens"

One of a series of person-on-the street interviews on the subject of democracy. Nice vox pop quality, short and pithy, could be sprinkled throughout a democracy-themed talk/call in show to promote discussion.

Comment for "Harvey Pekar: My Father" (deleted)

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Harvey Pekar: My Father (deleted)

A belated personal tribute from a son to his father, full of regret and anguish over things unsaid, and feelings unexpressed. Would make a thought-provoking, but not uplifting, addition to a father's day line up. Great voice, simple delivery.

Comment for "Habits of the Heart - "Sampler""

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Habits of the Heart - "Sampler"

A nice overview of the series, what it is about , it's style and ethos. An innovative approach to covering religious issues; for instance I had never really considered the religious content of The Simpsons nor the existence of drive-in churches! This sampler seems to be more Fresh Air/NPR news mag than This American Life; a good mix of interview, first person stories, vox pop etc.

Comment for "Hitchhiking Cop Improv" (deleted)

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Hitchhiking Cop Improv (deleted)

A peak behind the scenes of a radio piece on hitchhiking. The listener is right there on the side of a busy highway in CA, where 3 friends argue about who gets to play a cop in the recreation of a rather undramatic scene in a radio piece that must still be in the pipeline; the piece really focuses on the type of friendly banter, and at times abrasive bickering, that goes on between friends who've known each other a long time. Nice use of music and stereo sound.
A note of caution for broadcasters, the f-word is used.

Comment for "Old Together"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Old Together

This warmed the cockles of my heart; but it is not sickly sweet. For such a short piece, it is packed full of heartfelt, love filled words and memories. Gives hope to the married amongst us, unusual in these times.

Lucky producer's wife!

Comment for "An Anatomy of Humanity"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of An Anatomy of Humanity

Unusual, given all that has been written about the event, to find a new angle on the events of 9/11. Really LOVELY writing, drawing on producer's new life in alaska, and medical background, but a lot to take in in one sitting; I wanted to pause and digest. Touches on the common theme of helplessness that all of us felt, far from NYC and DC. This is utlimately about the aftermath, recovery and renewal, and how we heal, in our individual ways.

Comment for "Mahmoud Abbas Peace Meditation"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Mahmoud Abbas Peace Meditation

Calming interstitial spot, provides an opportunity for contemplation and relaxation between current affairs pieces, very much of "All Songs Considered" ilk.